I am a ME and have cnc machines ranging from the handibot up to a 5x10 commercial cnc router. Yes in front of audiences who have never heard of hand routers, or computer controlled tooling, or hype, its going to sound like the wright flyer 50 years early. Hands-On The Shaper Origin: A Tool That Changes How We Build My wifes embroidery machine has the find the X or in its case the crossing on an 8. But what really sells me isnt the feature list, its the evidence of the testing and development smarts exhibited by the company behind it. But I think Id feel a lot more comfortable with an ordinary gantry machine, even a small one in the $5k range, that doesnt depend on anyone else to keep it working. Since this printer works with different types of materials like wood, plastics, acrylic and you can use it to create anything you want, including toys, tools, accessories, furniture, and a lot more. Shapeoko Pro Review [2023]- Worth the Price? - MellowPine Its unreasonable to ask Shaper to design around this scenario a scenario that seems unlikely to happen given that theres simply no advantage to placing the optical tape on your stock any earlier than when youre actually going to be making cuts. Some time ago I worked in a factory which handled a lot of sheet metal and near the end of the last shift we used to load one of the CNC machines with a pallet of sheet metal. Tell me I cant turn the dials up to eleven and I wont turn them past three. It makes us more. Wed sum it up this way our: Most Budget Friendly:Shapeoko is most suitable for those on a tight budget, who want to give CNC-machining a go without spending nearly $2,000 on a machine. There is a learning curve like any computer driven tool. Ive fantasized about owning a Shopbot for years, but even if I could afford it, the chances that Id have a place big enough for it are even less. It works better if you have a table or if you make one. But likely faster than multiple machining steps and multiple assembly steps. An optical mouse has no idea where it is, all it reports is delta XY position. https://www.kickstarter.com/projects/2130625347/goliath-cnc-an-autonomous-robotic-machine-tool-for, Quote from: Rollin22Petes on October 06, 2017, 08:26 PM, Quote from: Timtool on October 07, 2017, 11:09 AM, Quote from: Richard/RMW on October 07, 2017, 01:27 PM, Quote from: bobfog on October 07, 2017, 01:34 PM, Quote from: Timtool on October 08, 2017, 04:19 AM, Quote from: Michael Kellough on October 08, 2017, 12:42 PM, Quote from: Svar on October 08, 2017, 12:44 PM, Quote from: ben_r_ on October 20, 2017, 01:03 PM, Quote from: Svar on October 20, 2017, 01:43 PM, Quote from: Michael Kellough on October 20, 2017, 03:30 PM, Quote from: antss on October 21, 2017, 09:09 AM. Most of the test rigs shown in this article were made using the device. The idea that it would be silly to let a CNC machine do its thing unattended is a bit silly in itself. This article literally claims this device is as transformative to woodworking as the saw blade. All the highlighted dominos are the ones thatOrigin is using to hold its position. Is that the case? Origin ships with 3 high quality bits. Forget about it. One of the coolest features, mentioned earlier, is that Origin can actually be used to draw the needed paths. there is no super solution, no solution that will satisfy all. https://community.shapertools.com/t/pcb-milling-with-origin/1321. Want to cut a 30mm hole? A CNC does almost everything the Origin can as long as it fits within the confines of the bed, but a Shaper Origin cannot do everything that a CNC can do. Without that luck the machine stopped somewhere during the night if one of the gazillion safeties was triggered, I think this machine would qualify for the really expensive kind in your view. The tape just does not work in real industrial environment. So its not that uncommon for new and different product to have a long waiting time. Shapeoko 4 Standard Cutting Area: 17.5" x 17.5" The next day the clever new apprenticedown at the blacksmiths shop is demoing his beta of his new Saw invention and looking for testers, investors, and a girlfriend. ), thats good enough for most purposes. The problem is going to be the price tag, I am thinking $900 at max before I would even look at it. When I was done working, that tape came right off as well, again, with no glue, and it had been sitting outside in the driveway getting sun through all that time. Ive done it, and prefer not to. Shapeoko comes with a z dependent dust boot free. Do you actually prefer if we hate on everything all the time? It's bare bones, but FAR cheaper and without ANY recurring software subscription costs. Theres certainly a trick to it. Read Help Document About This Version Version 1.6.10, 9/29/2022 It may take a few attempts at alignment to get the accuracy just right. Eliminating the time lost to complicated and cumbersome export procedures. Its a brilliant idea, and I bet wasnt simple getting it to work. But even I had to see it to believe it. What about metric units? A correctly tuned and calibrated (rack and pinion) milling machine should get to a resolution of ~0.075mm to 0.13mm. RW Id like to point out that the early indexed mouse pads were absolute position, more similar to todays graphics tablets than an optical mouse. CNC vs Shaper Origin | LumberJocks Woodworking Forum Been thinking a lot about this machine; firstly that its completely unaffordable for me, but mostly for the possibilities. Call the wambulance. Step it up. Industrial Designer Compares the Shaper Origin to His DIY Gantry CNC Router Share Watch on Years ago, industrial designer and Core77 contributor Randall Tyner built himself a 4'x4' CNC gantry machinein a recent video for Core77, Tyner gives a balanced review of pros and cons regarding the Shaper Origin versus his heavy duty CNC. Due to the material memory, sounds like you cant even have a set of over run boards, to allow you to get close to edges, because the second time you use them it will think youre cutting thin air. Otherwise I would go out and buy one this very afternoon. Since all it requires is the fiducial tape, it can make anything from the size of a matchbox to something as big as a thirty foot conference table. However, some reviewers say the instructions arent completely clear, which is a shame. But theres a problem. Think of a Mid-Century modern or a Scandinavian modern coffee table or desk. It is at the next point that Hackaday first interacts with Origin at a Makerfaire. First i love it. | Price Ranges, The 3D Printing Glossary of Common Terms and Acronyms, How to Find the Best SLA 3D Printer in 2022, How to Find the Best Multi Color 3D Printer [2022]. You cant cheat nature (physics), a cutting tool must be in a rigid fixture and guided by a rigid system, to be able to cut nice surfaces. Heck, i could even go to buy raw materials somewhere, have the tool powered by my car battery, and make pre-cuts in the parking to have pieces that fits in my car, and still maintain the sizes i want to cut later on. Hello CNC wizards! Shapeoko vs x-carve? : hobbycnc - reddit Heres my pre-order code if you want to save $100 and help me defray the cost of getting clever ideas into the hands of people who make more clever ideas. These are traits that you've come to know Origin for. Markan X with a pencil where you want the center of the hole. Im saddened to see it is still so far away, both in time, as well as only being available in the US. This platform used regular lead screws and linear bearings to perform the translations. The Goliath has already hit its funding target, with $754,080 in pledges on a $90,000 goal at press time. But i'm really not sure if it does actually live up to it's claims and may be more hassle than it's worth with my money better spent elsewhere. I saw the Shaper Origin a year later at this year's Connect event and had some time to talk to them and digest. You give it a few reference points on a surface and it uses that to track. And i think id rather pay more, but have my money until i can buy it to have it actually shipped quickly to me. The unit is indeed a hand-held CNC machine, with a spindle that is made by Festool. Take a 1.5HP one with a 10mm straight bit and you learn to never do climb milling again even for a couple of millimeter. lire Min. It's bare bones, but FAR cheaper and without ANY recurring software subscription costs. Schneider Airsystems) to have them follow their 'values' (in the sense of treating customers more like valued partners instead of victims) by offering the same guarantees as with Festool products: [mention]Gregor [/mention] I am guessing you dont work in software. The Shapeoko 3D Printer uses a Carbide Motion software that is compatible with Windows and Mac OS X. Sometimes they can be overwhelmingly so. The Popular Woodworking Magazine has named Shaper Origin + Workstation to its list of the best tools and products of 2020. Installing any CNC engraving machine can be tricky, which is why Inventables has a detailed step-by-step instruction guide on their website. The Shaper Origin is portable. And I doubt people with this level of skill are driven by the dream of making their living selling tape. If anything I spent more time on this article than I should have; considering I get paid the same regardless we can construe that this article actually cost me money to write. Got one you can send to me (free)? Poke in the table dimensions and the router takes care of the rest from its scan of the surface with the rows of tape applied. Thanks. The X-Carve had a major upgrade in 2017, fixing a lot of issues that people had with the previous model. Its as non-linear as they get, but fortunately its deterministic. If you cut over the fiducial tape, or find yourself needing more tape. But despite that limitation I still see advantages in certain applications. https://preorder.shapertools.com/ref/YELGJ4TJK, Really? Next time they try to cut a complex shape into a wall with their X-carve they will change their minds on this thing. Or a plausible alternative is to generate a quick and dirty system thats really cheap to implement. Initially, it will probably just be for my own use -- making templates mostly. Or it might be as easy as just photocopying a few pages of these stickers. Shaper Tools Will Blow Your Mind | Hackaday The standard Shapeoko 3 is only $1,320. And it is relevant to some of our interests. Try cutting a pass at a shallower depth, when cutting harder materials. Grizzly G0899 vs Laguna F2 | What Differentiates These Table Saws? It works using a dust shoe which attaches to the X-axis carriage and comes with a universal hose to fit any vacuum cleaner for easy removal. You can also use a smartphone or tablet. Available for PreSale now! and it doesnt look cheap. It comes with a tutorial to walk you through the basic features, and straight away you can see a preview of what youve made: The Pro version costs $19.99 per month, and gives you access to V-Carving (carving with a v-shaped bit), a customizable font library (sometimes referred to as Vectric Vcarve Desktop), and raster toolpaths. They are just differen machines for differend ways of working. The SO may handle signs using a V-bit, but it might not do a true V-carve that requires changing the depth of cut dynamically. Otherwise a combination of Shaper Origin (or second gen), Othermill and a From +1 3D printer would be an amazing shop where you could build a lot of things with very little space requirements at a reasonable price (below 10k$). Shaper Origin Gen 2 vs 1 First impression J Fred Beck 88 subscribers Subscribe 8.5K views 3 months ago This is an off the cuff, out of the box comparison between the original Shaper. catwastesoil.co.uk It goes without saying that a router cannot cut box joints on a horizontal sheet, as the bit is round and cannot cut proper corners: One problem any engineer faces when performing tests on a newly designed hardware is whether or not the problems they are seeing are a fault of the design, or just a fault of assembly. Very. Wouldnt it be cheaper and easier to get a CNC mill like the Shapeoko, remove the bed, and attach a RaspPi running OpenCV? I haven't measured the accuracy but so far have found the following: Thanks to those who have given their experiences with the shaper it's really helpful to hear your thoughts. It has Z axis movement and I would assume adjustable depth of cut. Shaper Origin for students? : r/shaperorigin - Reddit Well, when you need a new piece cut out of it, Originwill instantly recognize the arrangementof tape on it. The concept is great, you can do large projects but you dont require a large machine. . I suppose I could interpret that as suspicious if I wanted to. Assuming I could make room for it, of course. Any microcontroller could effortlessly perform the required transformation. It seems ???????????????? $10-15 for enough tape to cover a 48 panel, and you can only get the tape from Shaper (they claim its not possible to make it yourself). Residue wise though, hope they have something special there, considering your unconsumed materials may sit around a couple of years, and maximum non-residue guarantee on masking tape you can get is 60 days as far as I know. Use a V engraving bit and set the router to cut on the line. It is not a power work horse. I most definitely did not say that its uselessId love to have one, if the price (including the consumables) were more reasonable given its limitations and if I had more confidence in Shaper (the unexplained long wait, the wide spread of pre-order prices, and the weak details on the fiducial tape all make me suspicious). However, i find this tool awesome, and every time i see more about it, i want it more. I have seen a number of videos on that machine. (Comment Policy). They hope to have the first production units in peoples hands next year. Otherwise, awesome idea and good luck. Commenters be crazy. Id bet this Hackaday article is similar not paid, but a free unit. Nearly four years ago, Shaper joined the TTS Group to stand alongside other top industry brands including Festool, Sawstop, and Tanos. (I found the tape works well to keep wasps from turning the mirrors into homes. Where it comes in to its own is with things like furniture, something where the raw material and the final parts are larger than a desk but the user still wants the same level of results. Having nicely organized logs is the best way to make such determinations. There are hundreds of user-uploaded project ideas on their website, and a busy forum to keep in touch with other users. All in all, i like what i see, and i think i would have done things in a similar way if i had to (i mean the conception process, not the actual product). In our X-Carve vs Shapeoko comparison, well be looking at them both in detail. RW, I challenge you to bring a standard optical mouse from drawing board to box in store. The trapezoid in the middle is the actual live view of the camera. They built a testing machine from what they had around. Play slideshow. One of the main selling points of the Shapeoko is that it comes ready to go out of the box with no need to buy extras to make the machine work more smoothly. I got to use an early prototype at MakerFaire sometime ago and was impressed with it then. So why to you pre-order? Shaper Origin is an augmented reality CNC router. Covert advertising. It has automatic leveling, so it does not drill haphazardly. The Basket can track whos using the tool, who broke the tool, its current status, and much more. Before you begin cutting, travel over your entire design in Aircut Mode to verify that your tape metre will be healthy throughout the cut. Its like a magic pencil that summons whatever it draws. The main downside is the bed size for many affordable sizes, and the space needed for the larger bed size. Use my referral link for $100 off! We're committed to making precision cutting easy and accessible to everyone and your support, not to mention incredible work, keeps us focused on expanding and improving the Shaper System. I had no idea hackers hated tape that much. The Shaper Origin has no theoretical limits on work area. Ill bet dollars to donuts that isnt true. And whereas im all for reverse-enginering, and reproduce this in an open design (im all for open design, open hardware and open source -its even a purchase factor for me-, so if someone does an open hardware version of this, im all for it), while positioning with computer vision is a solved problem, doing it But i guess you cant put a price on refusing anything that doesnt suit your needs, consider it useless, and, all in all, rehashing the could be done with a 555, so it sucks. Expect to see the Shaper Origin all over the internet this week. Its unbridled hyperbole thats the problem. ), as it would cover the vast majority of my needs. I clicked through all the advertisement videos, and I can tell you this product is total useless for real industrial use. Its just a toy hobby machine, with real limitations. It will make for some interesting reviews as to see if the pros outweigh the cons. Although you could run it from an inverter or generator, would you really take your CNC bed machine out to a worksite every day? Similarly, I recently used some to tape up the gap in the mirrors of a car I had sitting outside being worked on without moving it from April until second week of August. Theyre not just giving away the tool in this case. A python script controlled it all. One thing that occurs to me is that if a lone-wolf maker were thinking of spending $1500 on a first CNC device, it might not be clear how this could be better than something like a Shapeoko; you'd need to be familiar with CNC already to appreciate how much effort goes into workpiece setup, edge finding, calibration etc., which is what makes . I could barely afford my $20 roll of toilet paper printed with Obamas face! Put on a UHMW baseplate to resist being scratched up byt the concrete, install a diamond burr, throw down some of the tape, put on some kneepads and after spending a minute sweeping it around to scan the area then position the design, start carving. Since it is not just another 3d printer or cnc mill it is good to see how it operates outside of the labs. ( worst . Shaper could be under a lot of financial stress and unable to meet the demand for many refunds. I asked too when I used it and remember it just being a setting in the software. TTS Tooltechnics Systems Acquires Shaper Tools, Inc. Pretty cool. My father always told me to buy a decent tool, spend a little more money and you can use it the rest of your life. If you want to clamp a fence across a sheet of plywood to run it along, youd only have to be within about 1/2 or so of straight. There are some CNC projects that can take many hours to produce. Less experience is needed to achieve cuts far greater than 1/100th of an inch using Origin. But Ive only a few times needed to cut something it couldnt directly handle and have so far always been able to find a workaround, so even though I have the space reserved for a full size ShopBot I dont see myself buying one in the near future. Only if you want it to fly right out of your hands and crash into mars . custom router spindle manufactured by Festool. A Shaper Origin is for things like mortises and tenons. By moving the magnet closer and furtheraway from the plate they can dynamically adjust the load by inducing eddy currents in the metal. So whats the big deal of spending a few bucks on a reel of duct tape? With the Origin, you have to buy the same router bits AND the fiducial tape, and the tape costs a hell of a lot more than a few bucks. Theres at least one portable gantry device that does this, and thats all it does. However, which one you pick will depend on certain things: how much experience you have, which features matter more to you, and so on. None of them have pictures of the mad hacky original version. Gen2's "tower," for one thing, has been redesigned to house a 5.5" high resolution display a 25% increase in screen real estate. The reviewer specifically says that they (the manufacturer) tried making their own, but it didnt give them the accuracy they really wanted. Win win! Extreme magnification like a mouse uses only works in mouse-like cases. Come on. The waste board is designed specifically for the X-Carve and has pre-drilled and counterbored holes to attach the clamps. Arduino is CHEAP and OPEN-SOURCE Not a chance. To get the maximum accuracy, you have to make sure everything is calibrated exactly right, which includes adjusting belt tension (which, as we mentioned, has been an issue for some people), adjusting the V-Wheels, and making sure any modifications youve made to the machine arent impacting the accuracy. The tape seems like how machine vision was handled in 1980s, mark up the thing you want to see with reference points. simms headwaters pro waders; jordan cabernet sauvignon sweet or dry; ubs arena parking problems. Copyright 2023 l Total3DPrinting l A Venture 4th Media Company. Home; Professional Development; About Us; Contact us From what you're saying it sounds like a clean cut is doable but can be a bit of a finickity process to achieve it consistently. Decrease your plunge speed and make sure Origins base is on a single surface and try again. Do you have an intern route wood all day long, keeping a subjective log of the spindles performance? Based on my limited knowledge, I'm thinking the Shaper Origin may be able to do what the pantorouter does for a little more cost but I'd have to build some jigs and fixtures and the outcome maybe wouldn't be as accurate. the asking price. In this video, I put the Shaper Origin through a very simple test to see what it's like, and how long it takes to set up for the cut. First lets get one thing clear. What can it do that other CNC tools either cant or ones that can cost much more than $2,000 and are larger and more cumbersome to setup, and require the setup to be repeated when moved? In fact, most of the time, the actual object in question has existed in some form or another for years. Plus, unlike a large format cnc machine, its incredibly portable so if you wanted, you can take it with you on a bike rather than needing a van. Down to the hobby stuff: None of them have the cool test rigs and hacks that went into it. It would bring the ability to design items with complex connecting shapes and be able to do so the same every time. Great tool, if your day to day work regularly requires you to cut complex and precise holes on site and in place rather than allowing you to use a CNC in your shop then assemble on site. Simple & Cheaper CNC Shaper | Hackaday.io It will not replace any working cnc router or mill. california high school football stats Some people prefer to have CNC software you can install onto your computer for this reason. :P. Ill bet they will eventually support Metric if/when this becomes a common product. A large portion of the algorithms were developed on this iteration. If it lives up to all its claims then it's worth it just for that extra accuracy for situations where you would otherwise have to make a complex jig, or for actually making a complex jig or a template etc. From that day onward the work is never the same again. Use my link and save $100: https://preorder.shapertools.com/ref/79WYV8BW6, What id like to see is this cutting metal (maybe V2), not think metal or anything, just 1-3mm. Its an accurate router that cant go as close to edges and needs a rather large minimum amount of area for it to know where it is. I have had my Shapeoko 4 XL for well over a year now and absolutley love it. Instead of considering that people only want that to show off, try be less condescending and consider other point of view A rocket ship is just a cylinder with some explosions behind it. More User Friendly [Best Overall]:X-Carve is better for those who need a little extra support, either from Inventables or from other X-Carve users. And to all the people that are bitching about still having to physically move the tool: REALLY?! Why? Have the many failed (or at least disappointing) Kickstarter campaigns taught us nothing? I broke some ribs wrestling yesterday and reading that comment was pretty painful. It's intuitive, doesn't require dedicated space, and can provide lots of shortcuts to complete projects quicker and with less stress. and how accurate is it really? The triangle in the middle is a menu button. The reviews are almost always positive because it seems writers dont go out of their way to find and then complain about equipment that totally sucks. Both the Shaper Origin and a CNC require learning a lot of software to use it well. And no, you do not give a $20/hour worker responsibility over a multi million dollar machine.